A day after
India carried out an airstrike in Balakot on a JeM camp on February 26 killing
some terrorists, Pakistan retaliated by sending a package of more than 20
Pakistan Air Force (PAF) planes to conduct a similar attack.
![]() |
| PAF F16s take off for a sortie |
![]() |
| PAF's Mirage-III EAs |
![]() |
| PAF JF-17 |
The PAF contingent was led by eight American F-16s along with four French Mirage-III EAs and eight Chinese JF-17s. They fired 11 H-4 1,000 kg bombs from a 50-km range inside their territory on February 27.
Out of these, only four F-16s ingressed into Indian territory. The Mirage-III EAs released the standoff H-4 1,000Kg bombs and the rest of the planes held back at various positions to confuse Indian radars about the exact nature of the strike aircraft as well as provide the four F-16s with a kind of air cover.
On the Indian side, at least six aircraft were in the air at that time. Two were upgraded Mirage-2000INs and the rest four were Su-30MKIs. Upon detecting the four inbound PAF fighters, two IAF MiG-21 Bisons were scrambled as five of the six aircraft were not close enough to reach the F-16s in time and the sixth aircraft — a Su-30MKI — was too expensive an aircraft to risk in a 4:1 aerial combat.
The reason why IAF trusts the MiG-21 Bisons so much is due to the stellar record they have had since Cope India 2004 where they had routinely trounced bigger and better aircraft like the F-16 and F-18 in aerial battles. Be it Fed Flag or Garuda V or the later editions of Cope India, IAF’s MiG 21 Bisons and MiG 21-73s have proven to be agile, nimble and fast fighters that can flummox bigger, better and slower fighters in lightning fast and short air combats.
![]() |
| IAF's Su-30MKI |
IAF’s philosophy of using them is simple — a Su-30 MKI acts as a mini AWACS and can direct two to six MiG-21s at various targets. A Su 30MKI’s “NIIP N011M Bars” radar can track 15+ targets (the actual number is classified) and engage four simultaneously. The radar’s maximum air-to-air detection range is over 400 km when used in an airborne early warning role and when used for intercepting role, the range against a typical fighter-sized target is 140 km head-on. However, it drops to 65 km in a tail-chase mode.
India’s MiG-21 pilots have perfected this art of pack hunting and such tactics have been further honed in India’s Tactics and Air Combat Development Establishment (TACDE) or in short, India’s “Top Gun” — of which Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman is a product and has taken part in various air combat exercises overseas like Cope India and Red Flag.
Varthaman and his wingman thus were very confident of what they were doing when they raced after the four F-16s. It was at this point that the Su-30MKI pilot got a shock. Till now, all they had envisioned was an aerial display of threat and counter threat like that had happened between an F-16 and Mig-29 in in 1999. The Indian pilots knew that Pak F-16s now had a BVR weapon — the US-supplied AIM 120C AMRAAM — but they were confident that Pak will not use them due to US-enforced constraints. However, the Su-30MKI pilot saw that, one after another, five AMRAAMs were fired towards him. He, till now, had not fired any of his R77 Adder missiles at the F-16s because of the “do-not-fire-until-fired-upon” rule but he was now busy dealing with the missiles that came after him.
Thanks to the Israeli ELTA jamming pod, the Su-30 MKI would defeat all the missiles. But during those few precious minutes, the MKI failed to act as a mini AWACS for the MiGs and could not help jam the missiles that were shot at them.
The PAF F-16 pilots, it seems, had done their homework and targeted the Su-30 first to take it out of action but were surprised by the speed of the MiGs which were now upon them and at a higher altitude — which is a position of advantage. This forced the F16s to turn back and Varthaman, seeing his opportunity, made a shallow dive to get into position to fire his R73E missile. The F-16 took evasive action but failed to escape the missile and went down. Varthaman’s wingman, meanwhile had taken evasive manoeuvres as he saw a missile was coming towards him. Varthaman too saw the missile approach warnings but by then, it was too late for him. His jet was hit and the rest was well documented by all the news channels.
But the question is, who shot the two missiles at the MiGs? By the time the Su-30 MKI had defeated all the missiles and got back to its position, everything was over. The MiGs had lost AWACS coverage for those crucial few seconds and had gone after the F16s relying on their own radars but missed the other four F16s and eight JF17s that were backing them up.
Speculation is strife about which aircraft shot the two missiles at the MiG-21.
Logic says it must have been one of the JF-17s as all the F-16s would have by now turned tail because they are too expensive to gamble when one has already gone down.
Another reason why it might not have been the F-16s is by this time, the Su-30MKI would have been in a position to retaliate, which might have played in the minds of the F-16 pilots.
This means, it was the JF-17s which were coming at another angle that took the shot using their Chinese PL-12 BVR missiles because they were further off from the Su-30MKI but just in range to target the MiGs.
However, Pakistan’s Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi has now identified two pilots who were involved in the aerial battle that took place on February 27 and one of them is Wing Commander Nauman Ali Khan who is a veteran pilot belonging to PAF’s No 5 Falcons squadron.
The only aircraft they operate are F-16 Block 52s. So, either Khan was the pilot that targeted the Su-30MKI or he was the one to shoot Varthaman down. The only hint here is that Qureshi praised him for “attacking” an Indian aircraft and not downing it.
![]() |
| Tejas tandem seater cockpit (Picture taken from http://ajaishukla.blogspot.com) |
![]() |
| HAL's Tejas assembly line |
So, a month after the incident, I am sure IAF has already dissected the entire operation. The air-to-air scenario in the subcontinent has changed drastically in the last five or so years due to the introduction of AMRAAMs and PL-12s and if IAF wants to hold on to its superiority, it needs to be at the top of its game and evolve new tactics and introduce new missiles as well as aircraft in its fast-depleting inventory.







No comments:
Post a Comment