Saturday, 6 April 2019

India and her submarine procurement fiasco

The Amur-class submarine showing vertical launch system (VLS) for Brahmos cruise missiles. This submarine is one of the contenders for India's Project 75(I)
The Amur-class submarine showing vertical launch system (VLS) for Brahmos cruise missiles. This submarine is one of the contenders for India's Project 75(I) 


The ministry of defence (MoD) on Wednesday (April 4, 2019) added another Act to its own version of “Comedy of Errors” when it comes to submarine procurement for the navy. 
PTI reported on April 4th, that in a ‘major move’ the MoD started the process to acquire six advanced diesel-electric submarines under the ambitious “strategic partnership” (SP) model at a cost of around Rs 45,000 crore.
The submarines, fitted with anti-ship cruise missiles (preferably Brahmos) and other lethal weapons, will be constructed in India jointly by an Indian defence major and a foreign submarine manufacturer under the Project-75(I) programme.
Sadly, this major move has been taking place since 2008 and the project’s progress can now be calculated by the same principal of the famous mathematical problem of a monkey climbing a greased pole where he jumps up three feet only to slip down two.
Sources, PTI reported, said the Expression of Interest (EoI) will be issued to leading manufacturers of advanced submarines in four weeks.  The defence ministry, the report said, has started the process for selecting both the Indian and foreign defence entities for the Rs 45,000-crore project.
Most do not know what to make of this. Does this mean the project is finally gathering steam or will it just lapse like it has done so many times in the past? So much so, that most believe that the project has become like the famous Schrödinger's cat — it’s at the same time both alive and dead.
From 2008 to 2019, the Indian public has been forced to bear witness to a farcical theatre of the absurd by the GoI, MoD, defence acquisition council (DAC) and cabinet committee for security (CCS).
In case of Project 75 (I), the initial Request for Information (RFI) was already issued in 2008 to Armaris, HDW and Rosoboronexport for six submarines with air-independent propulsion (AIP) and land-attack capability.
The project was re-planned in 2010 and after DAC’s approval, RFI was re-issued in September 2010. The RFI lapsed multiple times till 2013 when the renewed RFI was rejected by CCS.
In 2014, CCS in all its brilliance decided to build all the submarines in India. Along with the state-owned Mazagon Dock, Hindustan Shipyard, and Cochin Shipyard, privately-owned shipyards like Larsen & Toubro and Pipavav Shipyard were now allowed to bid for the project in collaboration with a foreign shipyard.
In June 2017, it was reported that the BJP government had now decided on a contract for construction that would be awarded under “Strategic Partnership" policy, which would eliminate state-owned shipyards from contention. However, this approval too lapsed in February 2018. In January this year DAC renewed the approval and now the MoD is slated to issue an EoI in four weeks’ time.
No wonder nobody in defence circles is keeping their fingers crossed this time. By our usual standards, even if by mistake the government signs the transfer-of-technology ToT deal, which is highly doubtful given the polls are around the corner, the project is bound to falter.
If NDA wins the election, MoD will have to deal with a new minister, who will need to reacquaint himself or herself with the ministry. This takes time and the approval will, again, lapse. If UPA wins, then there will be a complete change in Cabinet and the acquisition will be reviewed by the new councils and the approval will surely lapse again. So, it is highly doubtful that this project will see light of the day anytime soon.
Sadly, the history of submarine projects in India has always been one of delays, apathy and adoption of a procedure that embodies utter lack of common sense.
Project 75, Project 75(I)’s predecessor, for instance, was born on 1997 under which the Indian government planned to buy 24 diesel-electric submarines and by 1998 India had begun negotiations with Direction des Constructions Navales (DCN) —a French industrial group known for naval defence, known simply as Naval Group post 2017 — for four Scorpène-class submarines of which two was to be built in Mazagon Docks Limited from knocked-down kits.
Till this time, there were two schools of thought that vied for importance in the Indian Naval decision-making circles. The most prominent was the one that backed investing in aircraft carriers, which, they said, would be the future of naval warfare enabling the navy operating it unmatched force projection capabilities in any given region. The other school of thought maintained that aircraft carriers were nothing but big targets that can be picked off easily by stealthy submarines and that future wars would see an unprecedented use of any navy’s underwater arm.
Navy thinkers, however, were convinced by the first school of thought and wanted to buy the Kiev-class aircraft carrier Admiral Gorshkov that the Soviet Navy had inducted in 1987 and decommissioned in 1996. After years of negotiations, the deal was finally inked in January 20, 2004. The aircraft carrier was finally inducted into service, after extensive repair and refurbishment, on November 16, 2013 as INS Vikramaditya.

Indian Navy's aircraft carrier INS Vikramaditya also shows three Mig29K aircraft
INS Vikramaditya


However, after the Kargil war in 1999, Indian planners had nonetheless “realised” the importance of an underwater arm and had approved of a 30-year submarine building plan that involved two parallel production lines Project 75 and Project 75(I).
It would take India another six years to sign a series of transfer-of-technology (ToT) contracts to build six submarines in Mazagon Docks Limited with Armaris — a joint company set up in 2002 by DCN and THALES.
DCN was then designated as the prime contractor in partnership with Navantia — a Spanish state-owned shipbuilding company.
Steel cutting for the first submarine of the project would begin only a year later, on December 14, 2006 and hull construction was started on May 23, 2007. The project was plagued by one delay after another and by 2014, it was running four years behind schedule.
The first submarine INS Kalvari was finally launched in October 28, 2015 and sea trials began on May 1, 2016.

First Indian Scorpene-class submarine INS Kalvari firing a torpedo during its aea trials
INS Kalvari


However, it was time for the next fiasco as the Black Shark torpedoes, from WASS, that were supposed to arm these submarines was cancelled due to corruption allegations against its sister company AgustaWestland.
For now, these state-of-the-art submarines will have to do with ancient and obsolete Surface and Underwater Target (SUT) torpedoes.

INS Chakra-II the Nuclear-powered attack submarine that India leased from Russia
INS Chakra II


It is common knowledge that the submarine arm of the Indian Navy is now very weak.
Navy now has only one Arihant-class SSBN, one Akula-II class SSN (leased from Russia), and 14 SSKs which includes nine Sindhughosh-class (or Russian Kilo-class) submarines from the eighties, four Sishumar class (or German Type 209) submarines also from the eighties and a lone Kalvari class (Scorpène-class) submarine.
India lost a newly-refurbished Sindhughosh-class submarine INS Sindhurakshak on August 14, 2013.

INS Sindhughosh


A Shishumar-class submarine

With no progress in Project 75(I) in view, what any sane-minded MoD would have done is gone for three more AIP-enabled Scorpène-class submarines from Mazagon Docks Limited which by now has mastered the process of building the submarines. The dock authorities in 2017 had said that it would be able to churn out the next batch of submarines within three to four years of getting the green signal.
 The next logical step is going for a govt-to-govt deal with the French for their nuclear-powered Barracuda class SSNs. Or at least an Australia type deal for Shortfin Barracuda Block 1A — which is a diesel-electric version of the SSN design.
Going by Indian Navy’s future blue-water ambitions, it needs at least 12 SSNs and 8 SSBNs and 22 SSKs and at least three aircraft carriers. 
India is already building four 6000-tonne Arihant-class SSBNs with design help from Russia. INS Arihant is already operational, INS Arighat is undergoing sea trials and is expected to be commissioned late in 2019 or in early 2020. The other two will follow before 2025. After that India will embark on building four 12,000-tonne SSBNs for which nuclear reactors are already being fabricated. 

INS Arihant



Also in the works are a batch of six SSNs that India is building with major design inputs from Russia. These will be starting to go into sea trials sometime in or after 2030. But India need SSNs now and leasing one from Russia will not work in the future as India's assets in the water, which will need protection, will grow by then. The Navy would need at least four SSNs to protect two of its aircraft carriers and two SSBNs which would be in service. 
Why Indian Navy is so hung up on Project 75(I) is its vertical launch capability of Brahmos cruise missiles. These subs, with their extended-range Brahmos would be a deadly force to reckon with in the sub-continent, Indian Ocean and off course in South China Sea where these will be able to threaten Chinese aircraft carriers from stand-off ranges if the can be built on time. But as to when we can expect this project to finally bear fruit is hard to tell and all we as Indian Navy’s well-wishers can do is follow
Alexander Dumas’ advice in the concluding line of his adventure novel "The Count of Monte Cristo" – “Wait and hope”.


Note: 

SSN        - nuclear-powered general-purpose attack submarine

SSBN     - nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines
SSK         - diesel-electric submarine
AIP         - Air Independent Propulsion System




No comments:

Post a Comment

India and her submarine procurement fiasco

The Amur-class submarine showing vertical launch system (VLS) for Brahmos cruise missiles. This submarine is one of the contenders for In...